The first part of this series explored how our often unrecognised shame hides beneath behaviours like perfectionism, overwork, withdrawal, defensiveness and a constant need to remain in control. These behaviour patterns are ways we have learned to feel seen and significant and to mitigate a fundamental underlying fear: If others see what is lacking and flawed in me, will they still accept me?This fear is relational more than it is about something that happened. It is about what the event reveals about our worth and whether that would place our belonging at risk. Our way out of this fear is therefore not individual alone, but also relational.When shame becomes a storm
In The Gifts of Imperfection, Brené Brown uses the metaphor of a shame storm to describe what happens to us when shame completely overwhelms our perspective. In such a shame storm, our bodies have a strong visceral reaction, our minds get flooded and stuck on what happened, while harsh negative self-assessments (judgments) are held like hard facts. We may feel an urgent need to hide, explain, attack ourselves or lash out at someone else (1).Brown’s broader shame-resilience work overlaps beautifully with ontological coaching as it invites us to learn to recognise the embodied signs of a shame storm. These signs include a racing heart, a dry mouth, blushing, or experiencing tunnel vision. Growing in how we observe our bodily experiences and learning what they mean helps us to respond in a way that does not intensify the shame storm (2).Her framework then invites us to reach out to a trustworthy person and to bring our experience to speech in the presence of a safe person. This goes directly against the impulse to hide for safety and it counters the fear of loss of connection or belonging. Countering the silence, secrecy and judgment of shame
Choosing a safe person to share our shame storm with is crucial. A safe person is someone who has earned our trust and who has the maturity to remain present without responding with shock, pity, gossip or judgment. A safe person does not minimise or rush to conclusions. A safe person stays connected and present as the powerful mixture of emotions, the meanings we have attached to the experience come gushing out. Then, when the visceral and emotional storm is dissipating, a safe person helps sort through our interpretations and assessments and facts. This kind of connection challenges shame at its deepest point. We allow something hidden to be seen and we are reminded that the relationship can survive the sharing. We may still need to apologise to someone, repair harm, change our behaviour, but it no longer carries the fear of not belonging and not being accepted.Brown describes secrecy, silence and judgment as the fertile ground in which shame grows. Speaking about what happened counters secrecy and silence, while compassion and empathy interrupt the expectation and harshness of judgment (3).Being known changes the story
Psychiatrist Curt Thompson in The Soul of Shame, in arguably one of the most impactful books I ever read, draws on interpersonal neurobiology and Christian theology when he describes shame as a force that fragments our inner life and that distorts the stories we tell about ourselves and how it isolates us from others (4).Thompson focuses not only on how we respond when we encounter a shame storm in daily life, he argues that telling our life stories within safe relationships actually heals the meaning we make of our life stories which in turn has a powerful impact on our core identity. Telling our stories helps us integrate our life experiences and as our stories are heard differently than we hear them, we begin to experience ourselves differently. Being known in this way powerfully counters our fear of losing belonging when we are truly known for who we are.Being seen and known by God
In Genesis 3, Adam and Eve encountered shame and became conscious of their nakedness. They covered themselves, hid from God and blamed one another. Shame set in and changed how they experienced themselves, each other and God.God, however, moved towards them with the question, “Where are you?” Their actions had consequences, yet God didn't leave them hiding. The chapter ends with God making them garments and clothing them. Their own attempt to cover themselves was met by God’s relentless love and compassion.The fear beneath shame is that being fully seen will lead to rejection. Our Christian faith counters this fear profoundly. We are fully known by God and we are loved unconditionally. Such grace remains present even though it does not remove our own responsibility or diminish harmful behaviour. We can bring our shame into the light before God without first trying to make ourselves presentable. We can be fully honest with God without fearing rejection. Prayer becomes an encounter in which we allow ourselves to be known and seen in all our messiness rather than another attempt to perform or manage what can be seen.Developing shame resilience
When shame rises again, I invite you to notice what is happening in your body, emotions and language. Ask: What happened? What have I made it mean about me? What is mine to take responsibility for? What is still true about me?Share your story with someone who has earned your trust and who can help you see more clearly. Most importantly, I encourage you to bring the same honesty to God. Allow yourself to be found right there in the eye of your shame storm and hear the unchanging truth about who you are and how loved you are.Our shame resilience grows as we risk being seen and we discover how openness and connection cast out our deepest fear about ourselves or whether we belong.Until next time,Carine
References
(1) Brown, B. (2020) The Gifts of Imperfection. Hazelden Publishing.
(2) Brown, B. I Thought It Was Just Me (But It Isn’t): Companion Worksheet. The worksheet summarises recognising shame, critical awareness, reaching out and speaking shame.
(3) Brown, B. “The Power of Regret.” Discussion of secrecy, silence, judgement and shame.
(4) Thompson, C. (2015). The Soul of Shame: Retelling the Stories We Believe About Ourselves. InterVarsity Press.
**Painting: The Visitation by Irma Stern (South African Artist). Depicting Mary visiting Elizabeth